Explanation of suit for declaration and succession certificate in Pakistan
In suit for declaration &
succession certificate in Pakistan explanation to Art. 203-B. Relates to
special laws and statues denominated as "Muslim and applying to Muslims
alone and not to Divine and religious law of Muslims. Section 4 held contrary
to Injunctions of Islam not correct. Death of any son or daughter of propositus
before opening of succession. Children of such son or daughter, if any, living
at the time the succession opened, shall per stripes receive a share equivalent
to share which such son or daughters as the case may be would have received if
alive.
More about suit for declaration & succession certificate in Pakistan
In the suit for declaration &
succession
certificate in Pakistan entitlement to inheritance under S. 4 of
predeceased son the object and rationale behind S. 4 is to ameliorate the
distress of those unfortunate children whose father and mother were snatched
away by death in the life-time of their grandfather. Such orphan grandchildren
are sought to be compensated in such a way by giving the share in inheritance
to which their father or mother would have been entitled. The express and
unambiguous phraseology and language of S. 4 leaves no obscurity or doubt that
"children of such are only entitled to inherit and receive share. The
expression "of such son" used in S. 4 does not possibly include
within its ambit the widow "of such son. Inheritance mutation sanctioned
in favor of widow to the exclusion of predeceased son would be illegal being
violation of express mandate of S. 4. Succession. Daughter of pre-deceased son
of propositus.
To Inherit Property of her Father:
Question was whether being the
sole daughter of predeceased son of propositus she was entitled to inherit full
property of her father. Grandchild was not entitled to more than what could be
inherited by him/her from the parents according to Islamic Law. Findings of Courts
below that plaintiff was entitled to inherit full property of her father were
not in consonance of law by the Supreme Court. Plaintiff was entitled to only
half of share under Islamic Law of Inheritance. Impugned decree was modified
accordingly in suit for declaration & succession certificate in Pakistan.
What need to do is the case?
In suit
for declaration & succession certificate in Pakistan share of
predeceased son as referred to in S. 4 antithesis of per capita. This means a
share according to stock or root or family as against per capita which means
share per head. This assumes greater importance only where propositus leaves
behind a number of grand-children whose parents died during life-time of
propositus. Principle of succession in such cases would not be inheritance per
capita but per stripes i.e. in accordance with root or stock to which
grand-child belongs and would only get share to which grand-child is entitled
through his parent. In event of there being a single surviving grand-child
principle of per stripes is pushed to background but cannot be employed to
support a principle which militates against law of Inheritance. It was held
that finding of High Court applying per stripes rule of succession and
upholding inheritance claim of collaterals of predeceased son of propositus was
based on correct interpretation of S. 4 and did not merit interference by
Supreme Court.
Succession to share of predeceased son. Grandchild is not
entitled to more share than what could be inheritance from parents according to
Islamic Law. Estate would be divided in proportion of respective of
grand-children's parents. Heirs claiming through different lines of descent
would get their own shares as per stripes and not as per capita. In suit for
declaration & succession certificate in Pakistan provided for in S. 4 for
benefit of orphaned sons and daughters of predeceased's parent and meant to
remedy discrimination existing against grandchild whose parent died before
succession opened. Grandchild not entitled to more than what would have been
his share if parent was alive when succession opened.
Comments
Post a Comment