Bar to Suit for Declaration in Pakistan:
Chairman of Arbitration Council
has no power to issue certificate either rejecting divorce or holding the same
to be ineffective. Family Court being possessed of exclusive jurisdiction to
determine validity of marriage and suit for declaration in Pakistan and
permanent injunction cannot be filed in civil court. Determination of dispute
relating to false marriage lies. Determination of dispute relating to false
marriage lies within jurisdiction of Family Court. Section 23 would be no bar
to suit
for declaration in Pakistan and possession before Family Court. Judge
Family Court was competent to examine whether marriage certificate was executed
under duress and coercion. Finding of fact by two Courts is based on evidence
adduced by both parties. There is no misreading or non-reading of evidence
warranting interference in exercise of Constitutional jurisdiction, Petition
dismissed.
Suit for Declaration in Pakistan and Permanent injunction:
Term “Suit for declaration in
Pakistan” and “Permanent injunction” not to be confined to civil cases. Suit
for declaration in Pakistan along with permanent injunction regard less of its
timings can be filed by person other than spouses involved in cancellation of
marriage. Suit for declaration in Pakistan can also be filed by spouses against
third party with a view to prevent them from denying their marriage. Nature of suit
for declaration in Pakistan of marriage is of summary nature. Its main object
is to perpetually silence a false allegation or claim put forward by defendant,
of a marriage having taken place between defendant and plaintiff. It may
include a suit for declaration in Pakistan by a person falsely posing to be
spouse of defendant. It can be filed before Family Court even by a person other
than spouses involved in cancellation of marriage.
Suit for Declaration in Pakistan of Marriage:
Character of suit for declaration
in Pakistan of marriage is not altered by making additional prayer for
adjudging marriage certificate as forged and seeking its cancellation. Held there
was an air of utter reality in contention for husband/petitioner that suit, as
framed and filed by wife/respondent, could not be said to be a suit for declaration
in Pakistan of marriage and relief sought could only be granted by competent
Civil Court and not by a Family Court. Suit for specific performance of
agreement between spouses was valid. Earlier suit for declaration in Pakistan
filed by petitioner for custody of children had been dismissed by Family Court
and attained finality up till the Supreme Court. Second suit instituted by
petitioner to determine right of visitation based on an agreement between
spouses fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Family Court. Petitioner
had not agitated right of visitation in the earlier suit but it was deemed to
have been directly and substantially in issue in the earlier Suit.
What is the Principle for Res Judicata?
Principle of res judicata applied
in the case and Court seized with second suit could not try the same in view of
Section 11, C.P.C. Second suit was also not maintainable in view of Section 21
of Specific Relief Act, 1877 as it was based on an agreement which contained a
promise by respondent to arrange meeting of petitioner with minors till an
indefinite period. Both Courts below having rightly dismissed the suit and
appeal, revision was dismissed with Costs. Principle of res judicata with
regard to plea of Khula' is not applicable in case of dissolution of marriage. Wife
gets fresh cause of action to approach Family Court in view of fresh
circumstances and subsequent events which may take place between the parties
after withdrawal of previous suit. Bar on appeal from decree of Family Court.
Barring clause of S. 14 of the West Pakistan Family Courts Act, 1964 operated
where decree of maintenance was challenged to disentitle the decree-holder or
reduce the rate of maintenance allowance and the same was not applicable to
appeals for enhancement of maintenance.
For more information:
http://www.24article.com/legal-way-for-succession-certificate-in-pakistan.htmlhttps://www.ko-fi.com/Blog/Post/How-to-Solve-Suit-of-Declaration-in-Pakistan-C0C71E42N
https://runkit.com/ammywilson98/how-to-get-certificate-for-suit-of-declaration-in-pakistan
|
Comments
Post a Comment